top of page
  • Writer's pictureMatt Pinsker

The Right to an Appropriate Defense

A person's constitutional rights include the fundamental right to a defense. The Fifth Amendment guarantees everyone the right to a fair trial. Included in this right is the assumption of innocence. This means that until guilt is established, everyone is assumed innocent. Therefore, every defendant must have a defense counsel who can deliver the most robust possible defense.


In several criminal instances, the accused may not demonstrate their innocence. As a result, underfunded attorneys cannot conduct a comprehensive independent investigation, prepare a defense, or pursue clues that may lead to a genuine criminal. Travis Hayes and Ryan Matthews, convicted of murder at seventeen, illustrate this dilemma. In both instances, their convictions resulted in life without the possibility of parole.


It's not always possible to defend the guilty without a defense. First, the Crown Prosecutor must establish beyond a reasonable doubt that the defendant is guilty. Therefore, the accused must have behaved intentionally. It is rare for an unaware individual to commit a crime. In such situations, a person may assert the "automatism" defense, which happens when an accused person moves automatically (such as sleepwalking).


It is standard practice for attorneys to defend the unpopular. While no one can compel a lawyer to represent an unpopular client, the profession frequently celebrates its triumphs in doing so. Tom Spahn, a commercial litigator with McGuireWoods in McLean, Virginia, regularly advises Fortune 500 businesses on ethics, conflicts of interest, attorney-client privilege, and corporate investigations.


Defending the unpopular is a difficult task. Prejudice and hatred sometimes emerge from media depictions of the unwanted. This discontent is exacerbated in a populist climate where the presumption of innocence is under attack, and punitive sentencing is the norm. Therefore, attorneys must utilize their professional discretion and sensitivity when defending the unpopular.


The most effective strategy to safeguard the innocent against erroneous conviction is to furnish them with a vigorous public defense. Since 1991, when aggressive attempts began in Louisiana, 25 persons have been exonerated after serving lengthy jail terms. These unjust convictions are not exclusive to one region of the state and result from a lack of a strong defense during the trial and the initial appeal.


A competent criminal defense attorney has the means to construct a defense of the highest caliber. As a result, they can employ a top-tier attorney to defend their client against bogus criminal charges. Unfortunately, this form of protection is frequently unreachable because public defenders lack the workforce, money, and expertise to present successful defenses for every accused defendant. Due to this, society faces a significant risk of incarcerating innocent individuals.


A skilled criminal defense attorney can negotiate a plea bargain on your behalf. Consequently, the majority of cases never reach trial. In such circumstances, the defense attorney can bargain with the prosecution and persuade them of the defendant's innocence. Demonstrating the prosecution's error makes the trial more likely to drop the charges.

15 views
bottom of page